what it says on the tin, or in this case, the title of the blog. there are so many thoughts i have on this topic, neither of which are nearly coherent and put together enough.
what is it that makes the group nogizaka46 nogizaka?
is it their ephemerality? the long, swaying skirts? the french private girls' school concept? chances are, if you've tuned in to anything nogizaka has released this year (besides kimi loss, maybe) i reckon that your answer isn't gonna be either. it seems like once, that may have been the case, but these days, that concept seems far away. yet it lingers. it can be felt in interviews. put into words in songs. it can be read behind every line of (paraphrased) "thank you for the past 12 khk appearances, we wouldn't have been able to reach this point without the paths opened and led by our seniors, or without the love of our fans". as lyrics of theirs from literally the beginning of this year said, and promptly summed up, 尊敬は i love you!
you know, back when i was a 48g fan (and GOD, does it feel like that was ages ago), i never thought i'd get into nogizaka. i didn't think their songs were for me, and songs are, after all, the driving force behind my love for most groups (which partially explains why i've been so dissatisfied with their management this year) - between the energizing, driving rock-esque songs of nmb, my love for western bands and the way even my first proper dive into jpop was beyooooonds - i never thought the seemingly, for lack of better words, very demure, very mindful approach was for me. but there's so much more to nogizaka than that. fast forward what, five years later, and they're my favourite group of all time. they have my favourite generation of all time. i worried, at some point, that given that i Properly ended up getting into the group with the 5th generation joining, that the story would end once said generation would end up graduating. yet, just recently, a 6ki ended up becoming my 2nd oshi in the group, and i can see myself reaching 30 years and still being a nogiwota, for better or worse. despite the fanwars, the criticism, the absolutely abysmal behaviour from certain parts of the fandom and the (sometimes deserved, sometimes completely incomprehensible words from critics), something about this group keeps drawing me in, when typically, by now, i would've long given up. they're actually the group i've stuck with the longest. and so, i wonder. what makes nogizaka46, nogizaka?
that's a question i'd rather let linger in the back of our minds, both mine, and you, the reader's, alike. in the meantime, on a tangentially related note, i have very. complicated feelings about the very thing that makes nogizaka nogizaka.
on the one hand, i feel like i've most liked nogizaka when they weren't really /the/ nogizaka - after all, ikoma was the one that pulled me in with seifuku no mannequin, a former oomf's recommendation of oto ga denai guitar was what got me looping ANY of their songs, while the somewhat infamous (for, well, y'know, reasons) aruno reveal is actually what piqued my interest. short hair, great singer - i wouldn't have in a million years predicted what would later happen, yet the initial reveal felt like a created-in-a-lab recipe to draw mon in. and worked, it did! despite it all.
i feel like nogizaka stands at its tallest, to ME, when it's not what most people would have in mind when thinking about nogizaka - heck, among recent singles, despite my outward-facing beef with biriyani and zehibazu (for reasons STRICTLY related to aki-P/the mgmt, Lord knows i have plenty of gripes with those two for more or less (un)reasonable reasons), these two are some of my favourites, a-sides-wise, since i became a fan, if not ever.
it's complicated. i wonder if my feelings for both 5kis and the group as a whole would've been different were i to have met them at a different point in time. maybe before nanamin graduated and subsequently retired. maybe before momoko announced she'd be graduating. maybe before kaz left with a smile in the kimishikarareta MV. maybe before kiichan turned down participation in actually, the single, as a whole, barring her grad song. who knows. what i do know for a fact is that i think it wouldn't have been the same. heck, i'm sure of it. would it have been better or worse? truth be told, i don't know. what i do know is that i am glad that i discovered them when i did, and, despite it all, i wouldn't trade it for the world.
but there's a question that i keep thinking about, and it's not just the one in the title. what is it that makes this group, in particular, feel this particular. what should i call this. duty? devotion? pressure? unyielding standard? of respecting what the seniors have done, and following in their footsteps all at once. it's different from akb's relationship with the current, itomomo-force-and-yuiyui-ace-AND-pillar-led-renaissance and their golden era, it's different from just gratitude and wanting not to let others down. in romanian, there's this word that i can't find the english equivalent for - un jurământ. it certainly feels like that. it's more than a plea, more than something that's made up, it's something that drives the current nogizaka forward. always has been, in a sense. yet, all at once, for what it might be - the key behind nogizaka's successful passing of the baton between generations - it also feels like an inhibitor. like the proverbial sword hanging above their heads. the do-or-die.
i wonder if that's just in my head. it might just be. yet it feels like, on the one hand, like it's the utmost inner compass that's leading the members, who, despite it all, are trying to find their own way and make a name for themselves, yet when you look at them, as a group, it feels like there's a voice at the back of their heads, that poses the question: what would the seniors have done? what would the seniors do? and i find it fascinating.
i can't tell you how i quite feel about it, because i, too, haven't figured it out just yet. what i do know, however, is that its presence, seen or unseen, is there. you can feel it in the silence (or however those lyrics went, or something). there's more i want to say about this. yet the words are escaping me at (checks watch) 1:56am. might come back to this with more nuanced and eloquent thoughts later. big maybe, though. on a toooootally unrelated note, though, please do give nogizaka's my respect a listen! i wonder if they'll perform it at kouhaku. those lyrics would shine a new light on this whole topic, especially if you haven't kept up nearly as much with current nogizaka.
that being said, let's get back to the title. what is it that makes nogizaka, nogizaka? the songs? the costumes? the relationship that's so different from other groups? the members themselves? i can't tell you, because i don't know. it's been five years, and i'm still looking for an answer. i'm leaning towards the latter option, but it's not just that. i know it's not. maybe it's that very proverbial-sword i was talking about. (and between that, the parasocialism of it all, and everything in between, MAN do i wanna write a future thesis on this. i really do.)
between the kouhaku news, kimi loss, and other musings that will certainly come to mind, since i AM nogizaka's unpaid PR manager after all (/joke. i do strive to be that, sometimes, though. lately i feel like i've been doing a poorer job than i should've, though), i will be back with a future post. whether that's in an hour or in three months from now, i wouldn't know. but do know that i appreciate you reading all the way regardless!
until next time;
(addendum: y'know, it's funny. back when i was first getting into jpop, there was this absolutely wonderful person that i'll always be thankful for, even if they most certainly aren't reading this, that answered to my every question, offered me recs and links and resources, and where you could just feel the love pouring out. to this day, i still strive to be like them. i wonder if i've come even 1% close to it. yet i had one question back then, and it's funny how now, it seems like that question has returned, yet in a different form. what is it that makes people so open to sharing their favourite things? what leads us to want to get other people into our favourite groups? how come we spend so much of our time pouring in work and supporting these groups however we can, even with no real expectations of getting anything in return? what allows us to be so selfless for once? what's, y'know, the whole motif behind it all? i haven't quite found a proper answer to that either. just something to think about.)